What if Gaga /The Fame no but yes A Star Is Born

[Madame X]

I think Shallow would be Gaga's Sweet but Psycho in this case. 

[ProjectJoanne PronounsHe/Him]

I mean she kinda did with Red and Blue, and that didn’t really do a whole lot, definitely not as much as Just Dance did alone 

[paradox]

i SAID what if gaga/the fame no but yes a star is born

[little legend]

On 1/10/2021 at 8:38 AM, Madame X said:

I think Shallow would be Gaga's Sweet but Psycho in this case. 

[A Little Monsterrr Pronounsshe/her]

Until now, my last braincells are still confused with the title of this thread and the contents 

[little legend]

6 minutes ago, A Little Monsterrr said:

Until now, my last braincells are still confused with the title of this thread and the contents 

[danwasd Pronounsthey/them]

WHAT IF GAGA /THE FAME NO BUT YES A STAR IS BORN

[A Little Monsterrr Pronounsshe/her]

Just now, danwasd said:

WHAT IF GAGA /THE FAME NO BUT YES A STAR IS BORN

meme of the week wbk

[little legend]

Stop derailing my thread

[danwasd Pronounsthey/them]

2 minutes ago, A Little Monsterrr said:

meme of the week wbk

the meme of the millenium, as lazy gags herself said

[BenG]

The title makes me laugh so hard every single time

[little legend]

[GitHub Pronounsshe/her]

yes famous maybe less would be so potentially no singing but acting alright

[BenG]

2 minutes ago, GitHub said:

yes famous maybe less would be so potentially no singing but acting alright

Not you speaking the pup’s language

[little legend]

Let me start banning all of you .

I am going to be ruthless. 

[A Little Monsterrr Pronounsshe/her]

9 hours ago, little legend said:

Let me start banning all of you .

I am going to be ruthless. 

hey. apparently, your thread title became a meme. also i voted for you in pa911 member awards

[danwasd Pronounsthey/them]

I have to come up with sth bc this thread needs to be nominated next year 

[Agustin]

On 1/9/2021 at 8:14 PM, little legend said:

So what if Gaga's debut album wasnt The Fame but an album like A Star Is Born. So what if Gaga didn't debut with a dance album with huge pop bops but debuted with an album with huge and melodic ballads like Shallow , Always Remember Us This Way and I'll Never Love Again without dressing weird and etc.  And later in get career went from a Classic diva to a crazy pop star

What would happen? Would she become so huge? Would she considered the Adele of our times? And also then when she would go from Classic Gaga to Crazy Gaga would that be huge? Like Miley Cyrus in 2013 shocking transformation? 

SoThat i am asking ,if we reverse Gaga's career,would she became more successful? Would the GP loved her more or without The Fame as her debut album ,her career would have never been that huge

i personally don't think she would be as big because during that time, no one was doing it like her. like you said, adele. it wouldn't be normal if adele just made a rap album or an album like ARTPOP

[little legend]

On 1/12/2021 at 7:06 PM, Agustin said:

i personally don't think she would be as big because during that time, no one was doing it like her. like you said, adele. it wouldn't be normal if adele just made a rap album or an album like ARTPOP

That's actually an interesting approach. I want a lengthier explanation.

[danwasd Pronounsthey/them]

Phew, Thread of the Year