Better dancer: Madonna VS Beyonce

[Mario Spears Pronounshe/him ☆]

Sequel to this thread:

Again... Second Round. Who do Y'all think is the better dancer? Madonna? Or Beyonce? 

VS

 

Tbh, it's close! Madonna appears to be more versatile, more athletic and more agile. Not to mention that she's can do classical, tap, tango, salsa, actobatics, flamenco, etc. and  she's also has an awesome flexibility and is able to do many actobatic tricks (Bey also showed she was capable too, she's good at it too). 

As far as choreo goes, Madge has the slight edge, but Bey has the slight edge in dancing. 

I'm probably going to give Beyonce the slight edge bc she's the only one out of the pop girls who can dance who is a better dancer in her 30's than in her 20s or teens. But Madge ain't that far from ha because she also could still keep up. 

Thoughts? Who would y'all say is the better dancer?

Spoiler

@SapplerX @Nightwing @Zak @GitHub @BenG @JJ Monster @Dean of Clownmatica  @Gypsy Life

. ....  @ReadyGaga

 

Edited January 18, 2022 by Mario44

[Zak PronounsHe/Him]

Beyoncé by FAR

[Daddy]

[Miaou]

Beyoncé cause she can actually sing in the same time

[blue Pronounsshe/her]

Stating the obvious but Beyonce is very, very skilled in her singular dance style while Madonna is more of a generalist willing to try out different styles to suite the song/performance/era — it's hard to say who is better. 

I feel like Beyonce's performances for the most part lack the musical theatre element that I enjoy in early Madonna performances. I love the Blonde Ambition performances but at the same time, I think if someone attempted this nowadays we'd be like OK, Mrs. Roxie Hart (that's why it's so good!) 

 

[Mario Spears Pronounshe/him ☆]

On 1/18/2022 at 9:19 AM, Zak said:

Beyoncé by FAR

Agree. But both of them can do their thing! 

On 1/18/2022 at 11:27 AM, Miaou said:

Beyoncé cause she can actually sing in the same time

Yes! 

On 1/18/2022 at 11:23 AM, Sir.Sim said:

BEYCHELLA was LEGENDARY! 

On 1/18/2022 at 12:39 PM, blue said:

Stating the obvious but Beyonce is very, very skilled in her singular dance style while Madonna is more of a generalist willing to try out different styles to suite the song/performance/era — it's hard to say who is better. 

I feel like Beyonce's performances for the most part lack the musical theatre element that I enjoy in early Madonna performances. I love the Blonde Ambition performances but at the same time, I think if someone attempted this nowadays we'd be like OK, Mrs. Roxie Hart (that's why it's so good!) 

 

True

[Dean AYOster]

I want to say Madge but Bey keeping her vocals while dancing makes me give the vote to B

[Mario Spears Pronounshe/him ☆]

On 1/18/2022 at 3:39 PM, Dean of Clownmatica said:

I want to say Madge but Bey keeping her vocals while dancing makes me give the vote to B

true, i agree. when she dances, Bey can still sing flawlessly

Edited January 18, 2022 by Mario44

[ReadyGaga]

I agree with whoever votes Beyoncé because she can actually sing and dance at the same time. But when I see the live shows of Vogue, the dance moves of the Hard Candy / Confessions era and all the 80s / 90s when madonna was at her peak I am fascinated by her. MADONNA is able to do many more styles than Beyoncé, Madonna can safely do stunts in mid-air, have a cup of tea and dance immediately afterwards. This thread is meant to reward dance, not singing, so Madonna has my vote.

 

[ReadyGaga]

I agree with whoever votes Beyoncé because she can actually sing and dance at the same time. But when I see the live shows of Vogue, the dance moves of the Hard Candy / Confessions era and all the 80s / 90s when madonna was at her peak I am fascinated by her. MADONNA is able to do many more styles than Beyoncé, Madonna can safely do stunts in mid-air, have a cup of tea and dance immediately afterwards. This thread is meant to reward dance, not singing, so Madonna has my vote.

 

[Mario Spears Pronounshe/him ☆]

On 1/18/2022 at 4:23 PM, ReadyGaga said:

I agree with whoever votes Beyoncé because she can actually sing and dance at the same time. But when I see the live shows of Vogue, the dance moves of the Hard Candy / Confessions era and all the 80s / 90s when madonna was at her peak I am fascinated by her. MADONNA is able to do many more styles than Beyoncé, Madonna can safely do stunts in mid-air, have a cup of tea and dance immediately afterwards. This thread is meant to reward dance, not singing, so Madonna has my vote.

 

i agree. both of them in their 30s danced awesomely. Bey is captivating to me but M is also very fun to watch. also Bey dancing and giving great flexibility and stamina is sooooo damn impressive

Edited January 18, 2022 by Mario44

[Nemanja]

On 1/18/2022 at 4:25 PM, Mario44 said:

i agree. both of them in their 30s danced awesomely. Bey is captivating to me but M is also very fun to watch.

Madonna dance moves are best in her 50s

[Mario Spears Pronounshe/him ☆]

On 1/18/2022 at 4:27 PM, Nemanja said:

Madonna dance moves are best in her 50s

yes, at the S&S and MDNA Tours she was still GIVING.

[Adarsh]

Beyoncé for technique, Madonna for creativity 

[Nemanja]

i think both are great, but for me its Madonna, she really can do anything with dance moves. especially voguing. I'm not a fun of Beyonce music, or dance style, but i can't deny she's great.

[Mario Spears Pronounshe/him ☆]

On 1/18/2022 at 4:31 PM, Adarsh said:

Beyoncé for technique, Madonna for creativity 

lowkey this