Ceremony | CHROMATICA

[nope Pronounshe/him]

SFA next please and then ROM!!!

[ShesAMess]

The piano pigeon is better so I’m not too sad about this 

[SweetOreosOfHeaven Pronounshe/him]

Just now, Joannesrats said:

I think you’re confusing ROM with SFA! It’s okay, common mistake 

Let's see how fellow popa911'ians feel about that

[TINDER PronounsHe/Him]

Just now, Lorde Von Kok said:

So, you're telling me that Enigma is still here ? 

 

As it should, top 5 on chiropetrica!

[Joannesrats PronounsHe/Him]

Since when did everyone hate the best song on the album, Sine From Above?????

[paradox]

The million different opinions being fired around in this thread I can't keep up

[Battle For Your Life Pronounshe/him]

Just now, sickandtired2.0 said:

SFA next please and then ROM!!!

[SweetOreosOfHeaven Pronounshe/him]

1 minute ago, Lorde Von Kok said:

So, you're telling me that Enigma is still here ? 

 

deserves top 5 at least, wym?

[NotDoctor PronounsHe/they]

Just now, Joannesrats said:

Since when did everyone hate the best song on the album, Sine From Above?????

[SLAG PronounsHe/Him]

@Lorde Von Kok "Enigma" is a great song! It deserves to be in the top 10.

Edited October 24, 2020 by SLAG

[Joannesrats PronounsHe/Him]

It says a lot about an album when everyone has completely different favorites 

[Battle For Your Life Pronounshe/him]

2 minutes ago, Lorde Von Kok said:

So, you're telling me that Enigma is still here ? 

 

It's what she deserves. 

[Lorde Von Kok PronounsHe/Him]

@TINDER @SLAG @zcasx

 

 

Edited October 24, 2020 by Lorde Von Kok

[Joannesrats PronounsHe/Him]

Just now, NotDoctor said:

Am I laughing? 

[Impossible Princess Pronounsthey/them]

9. 1000 Doves (Piano Demo)

Average Score: 7.80

Highest Score: 11

@Franch Toast

Lowest Score: 1

@Party Favor @paradox

 

Comments

 

Spoiler

Username	Comments
Daylight Jokers	This would fit the ASIB track perfectly.
TINDER	Tear jerking, heart touching beautiful rendition of song! Loved this.
zcasx	Solid track.
Jonathan	This version is brilliant and should have been the album version.
Candy Gaga	Again adds nothing new to the album and the original is more polished this demo is a bit low quality.
BadGurlMadgr	Better than the album version
SLAG	I prefer the album version but Gaga can do no wrong whilst sitting at the piano.
joannesrats	Great vocals, but the piano instrumentation could have been a lot more interesting. I know it was only a ‘demo,’ but if you’re putting it on an album like Chromatica it needs more texture
HitTheBoat	A little bit better than the album version, but still okay-ish
Henry	Nice to have alongside the standard album version for context, but on it's own is not a standout.
Leolisa	A much better version of 1000 Doves, would have been no issues if it was the ballad of the album (alongside SFA).
kaelergrey	An amazing version of an already great song.
Brecht	A lot of people prefer this version but to me the album version is superior and y'all can seethe.
Gov Hooka	definitely better than the original track even if it doesn't have the bridge. I LOVE that she has a different chord progression here that gives it more melodic depth. Her piano playing is kind of basic in comparison to her other acoustic recordings, she just plays chords repeatedly, but her choice in chords captures the soul of the lyrics so well.
Party Favor	i never listened to this LMAO
Franch Toast	Such a gorgeous and personal song about lifting up one another.
GitHub	The superior version! I think sometimes production swallows her voice and I like the lyrics better
Freddy	Can’t believe I like this more than then album version, yet here we are 🤷🏻‍♂️
Mary Jane Holland	Perfect!
DonatellaPop	BETTER
justhislife	Better than the album standard version
Spinning Bottles	This song ruins the album a bit. This version doesn't add anything to the standard version and feels very unnecessary.
FRANZGA	it's kinda ARUTW's little sister
admin	I’ve also only heard this a few times. I love Gaga at the piano above all else, but the song itself is still a bit meh for me. Also, doesn’t it sound like she says two thousand doves in this version?

Participants

Spoiler

@Fame Romance @Daylight Jokers @corvus albus @ChromaticRaccoon @Lastrassi @TINDER @Ms I am a local @Ryusei @Born In Chromatica @zcasx @calmar @LordeVonKok @Mister G @Yanko @StormPulse @NotDoctor @FreeMyMind @Jonathan @Gypsy Life @Edonis @Doot @Candy Gaga @Aphrodite Lady @BadGurlMadge @Franz Ferdinand @Doncho @Miaou @Fernando @Steven @SLAG @Joannesrats @PanPikus @paradox @Drkitten @HitTheBoat @Kattys @Henry @gagarrhea @Leolisa @kaelergrey @Brecht @Gov Hooka @Party Favor @Bakugo @Andreu @lavenderblondee @Franch Toast @PETTY @GuiLM @ProjectJoanne @Joesuda @GitHub @Freddy @Mary Jane Holland @Clever Username @PrinceOTStorm @Musicisfreedom @nenhures @DonatellaPop @justhislife @raragaga @KatieJudasGaga4 @The Professor @Spinning Bottles @Noturregularmonster @sickandtired2.0 @FRANZGA @Twitter @admin @thehanyo

 

[SweetOreosOfHeaven Pronounshe/him]

Just now, Joannesrats said:

Since when did everyone hate the best song on the album, Sine From Above?????

Since they found out how it came to be and that triggered in people the realization that SFA is a dj brainless lame song with a pretentious but meaningless metaphor as it's motif

[SweetOreosOfHeaven Pronounshe/him]

Too early for her too. 

[Ms Arid Lost]

Ok, but why did 1000 Doves leave when Enigma or Sour Candy are still in it? I don’t get it...

[Andreu]

yikes... so many other songs deserved

[Battle For Your Life Pronounshe/him]

2 minutes ago, zcasx said:

SFA is a dj brainless lame song with a pretentious but meaningless metaphor as it's motif

This comment is more pretentious lmao

Edited October 24, 2020 by idontevenknow